CLP Corporate Legal Partners Schedule a meeting
HomePractice AreasAboutWritingCareersContact Schedule a meeting

Legal opinion on commercial disputes in India: assessing a claim before proceedings

Published , 11 min read

What should a legal opinion on commercial disputes assess before proceedings begin?

It should test whether the claim or defence can succeed, and how: the contract and the evidence, the right forum, whether the claim is within time, the realistic remedies and costs, and whether any judgment or award could be enforced. Advice from an advocate engaged for a pre-litigation matter is protected from disclosure without the client's consent. Salaried in-house counsels do not carry the same privilege.

Key takeaways

  • A legal opinion on a commercial dispute is an advocate's reasoned assessment of a claim or defence, on stated facts and documents, before money is spent on proceedings.
  • A suit, appeal or application filed after the limitation period is dismissed even if the other side does not raise the point.
  • A written, signed acknowledgement of the liability made before the prescribed period expires starts a fresh limitation period.
  • Where the contract has an arbitration clause, a court must refer the parties to arbitration if a party applies in time, unless there is prima facie no valid arbitration agreement.
  • The Supreme Court held on 31 October 2025 that an advocate's duty of confidentiality covers pre-litigation matters, but not the production of documents, and that salaried in-house counsels are not entitled to advocate privilege under Section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
  • A commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief cannot be filed until pre-institution mediation has been tried, and the time spent in it does not count towards limitation.
On this page (9 sections)
  1. What a legal opinion is, and what it is not
  2. When an opinion is worth getting
  3. What a useful opinion covers
  4. What to give the advocate
  5. Keeping the opinion confidential
  6. Steps before a commercial suit
  7. Using the opinion well
  8. Common questions
  9. Sources

A legal opinion on commercial disputes is an advocate’s written assessment of a claim or a defence, made before money is spent on a suit, an arbitration or a settlement. A demand has gone unpaid, a contract has been terminated, or a joint-venture partner has stopped performing, and the business has to decide what to do next. This guide explains when such an opinion is worth commissioning, what a useful one covers, what the advocate needs, and how to keep the advice confidential.

An opinion applies the law to a set of facts and documents, and says how strong the position is and why. It identifies what has to be proved, the evidence for each point, the risks, and the options. The Supreme Court has recognised that the practice of law includes non-litigious work such as giving opinions.

It is a reasoned view of risk, not a forecast of the result. Its value depends on the facts it is given: an opinion built on partial documents can be confidently wrong.

When an opinion is worth getting

The usual moments are:

  • before sending, or replying to, a legal notice;
  • before filing a suit or starting an arbitration;
  • before agreeing a settlement, or writing off a receivable;
  • when a board, lender, auditor or investor needs a considered view on a claim; and
  • when a claim is received and a defence has to be planned.

Time is often the first reason. Subject to the Limitation Act’s rules on extending and excluding time, a suit, appeal or application filed after the prescribed period is dismissed even if the other side does not raise limitation as a defence. A counterclaim is treated as a separate suit for this purpose. Two things can restart the clock, if they happen before the period expires:

  • a written acknowledgement of the liability, signed by the party against whom the claim is made; and
  • a payment on account of the debt appears in the handwriting of the person making the payment, or in a writing signed by, or on behalf of, such person (subject to statutory rules on interest on a legacy of single bill).

An early opinion can establish where the clock stands and whether either has happened.

What a useful opinion covers

AreaThe question the opinion should answerWhy it matters
The question and the factsWhat was asked, which facts are assumed and which documents were reviewed?It shows the limits of the advice.
The contractWhat do the governing law, dispute resolution, notice and termination clauses say?They often decide the forum and the first steps.
The forumIs there an arbitration clause? Is this a “commercial dispute” under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015?A court must refer the parties to arbitration if a party applies no later than its first statement on the substance, unless there is prima facie no valid arbitration agreement. Commercial disputes of a Specified Value follow the Commercial Courts Act.
Time limitsWhich limitation period applies, and when did it start?For breach of contract, generally three years from the breach unless a specific article applies, with special rules for successive and continuing breaches. Where no other article applies, three years from when the right to sue accrues.
EvidenceWhich documents and witnesses prove each element, and what is missing?Gaps found early can sometimes be filled; gaps found at trial are much harder to fill.
RemediesWhat can realistically be recovered, and is interim protection needed if assets may be moved?A claim worth bringing is one that can be turned into money or performance.
EnforceabilityWhere are the other side’s assets, and could a judgment or award be enforced there?A decision that cannot be enforced has little practical value.
Costs, time and alternativesWhat will each route cost in time and money, and is negotiation, mediation or arbitration better?It frames the commercial decision.

A “commercial dispute” covers a long list of transactions. Examples include:

  • ordinary transactions of merchants, bankers, financiers and traders;
  • construction and infrastructure contracts, including tenders;
  • joint venture, shareholders’ and partnership agreements;
  • distribution, licensing and franchising agreements; and
  • agreements for the sale of goods or the provision of services.

The Specified Value is at least three lakh rupees, or a higher value if the Central Government notifies one. A dispute remains a commercial dispute even where one party is the State or a public body; the firm’s Tender and Contract Law page describes its practice in government contracts and tenders. Where the contract has an arbitration clause, the firm’s Arbitration and Dispute Resolution page describes how such disputes run.

What to give the advocate

An opinion is only as reliable as the facts behind it. A complete first brief usually includes:

  1. The contract and every amendment, side letter and purchase order.
  2. The correspondence, including emails and messages, in date order.
  3. Invoices, ledgers and statements of account.
  4. Notices sent or received, with proof of delivery.
  5. Any acknowledgement or part payment by the other side.
  6. Board approvals or internal authorities relevant to the transaction.
  7. A dated timeline, and the names of the people who know what happened.
  8. What is known about the other side’s assets and where they are.

Keeping the opinion confidential

Indian law protects communications between a client and its advocate. An advocate may not, without the client’s express consent, disclose a communication made in the course of the engagement, the contents of documents learned of in it, or the advice given. The duty continues after the engagement ends. It does not protect communications made to further an illegal purpose, or facts the advocate observes showing that a crime or fraud has been committed since the engagement began.

Separately, under Section 133 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, no one can be compelled to disclose to a court confidential communication with their legal adviser. The exception is a person who gives evidence: they may then be compelled to disclose such communications as are necessary to explain that evidence. A party who gives evidence does not by that alone consent to disclosure by its advocate.

In a judgment of 31 October 2025, the Supreme Court gave directions on this privilege:

  • The privilege belongs to the client, and the advocate can invoke it on the client’s behalf.
  • The advocate bound by it is one engaged in litigation, or in a non-litigious or pre-litigation matter. Advice taken before any dispute reaches court is therefore within it.
  • Documents in the possession of the advocate or the client are not covered by the privilege, in a civil or a criminal case. In a civil case, production is governed by Section 165 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 and Order XVI Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the court decides any objection.
  • Salaried in-house counsels are not entitled to the advocate’s privilege under Section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. While Section 134 protects a person from being compelled to disclose confidential communications with a legal advisor, internal communications with salaried in-house counsel do not carry the protection of Section 132 and cannot be treated as settled privilege under Section 134.

The case arose from investigators summoning advocates in criminal matters, but the directions are framed generally, and the direction on documents expressly covers civil cases.

Two practical points follow. A company that wants its advice protected should commission it from an advocate engaged for the matter, not only from its in-house team. And the opinion should be shared only with those who need it, because each further recipient makes confidentiality harder to maintain.

Steps before a commercial suit

A commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief cannot be filed until the plaintiff has tried pre-institution mediation under the prescribed rules (and courts scrutinise bare assertions of urgency made to bypass this requirement). The mediation is to be completed within three months of the application, extendable by two months with the parties’ consent. The time spent in it does not count towards limitation. A settlement reached in it, reduced to writing and signed, has the same status as an arbitral award on agreed terms. An opinion should flag this step and allow for it in the timetable.

Using the opinion well

An opinion supports a decision: whether to sue, arbitrate, settle, defend or wait; how to answer a notice; and what to provide for in the accounts. It works best as a working document. Revisit it when the facts change, when new documents appear, or when the other side makes a proposal.

Commercial dispute advisory, including legal opinions on Indian law, is described in the Legal advisory section of the firm’s Supreme Court practice page.

Common questions

Is advice from in-house counsel privileged in India?

Not in the same way as advice from an advocate in practice. The Supreme Court held on 31 October 2025 that in-house counsels are not entitled to the privilege in Section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. While Section 134 addresses compulsion to disclose communications with a legal adviser, internal communications with salaried in-house counsel are not covered by Section 132 privilege and do not enjoy assured protection under Section 134.

Do documents become privileged once they are shown to a lawyer?

No. The Supreme Court has directed that the production of documents in the possession of an advocate or a client is not covered by the privilege in Section 132, in civil or criminal cases. In a civil case, production is governed by Section 165 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 and Order XVI Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and the court decides objections.

Does pre-institution mediation affect the time limit for a commercial suit?

Yes, in the plaintiff’s favour. The period during which the parties are occupied with pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 is not counted for limitation. The mediation is to be completed within three months, extendable by two months with the parties’ consent.

Can an acknowledgement of a debt extend the time to sue?

Yes. If, before the limitation period expires, the party liable acknowledges the liability in a writing signed by it or on its behalf, a fresh period runs from the date of signing. A part payment of a debt has the same effect if it is made before the period expires and appears in the handwriting of the person making the payment or in a writing signed by, or on behalf of, that person.

Sources

This article is general information about the law of India as at the date of its last review. It is not legal advice and does not create an advocate-client relationship. Readers should take advice on their own facts.